8ully, I find it comical that you are talking about mice and cheese in the same paragraph but the one has nothing to do with the other.
Tillamook is good for a supermarket cheese. I'm spoiled for choice around here. I recommend checking out Trader Joe's for inexpensive good cheese. They have decent quality and selection. The Double Gloucester (a mild orange cheese with onion and chives) is the bomb and the Madrigal (a mild swiss type) are both really good. We sometimes get their pecorino romano to grate over pasta.